June 29th, 2008The Martian General’s Daughter (review)
“In Europe,” said Father, “you will build a new nation and I will grow old. The Empire will pass away, and in a thousand years your descendants will read of it in a language that does not yet exist, and they will wonder if these things really were. And even if they think the story of our age is no more real than the tales of Camelot and Troy, those in ages hence will know who among us were villains and those who were loyal to the things they held dear.”
- Title: The Martian General’s Daughter
- Author: Theodore Judson
- Genre: Science Fiction
- Year: 2008
At the end of the twenty-third century the Pan-Polarian Empire is dying. Centuries old, encompassing most of the known world, mankind’s greatest empire is grinding to a halt in the face of domestic rebellions, insane leaders, corrupt officials, and plagues — and not just plagues that kill but something worse, a metal plague that destroys technology. When the Emperor dies, civil war is inevitable, and General Peter Black on distant Mars receives word that he has been endorsed by certain factions and moneyed interests for the position. Forced to join the conflict, Black and his illegitimate daughter Justa — the narrator of The Martian General’s Daughter — manage to make it back to earth on one of the last functioning starships, already failing from exposure to the metal plague. It is the world of the twenty-third century — and of Late Antiquity at the close of the Roman Empire, for the story of The Martian General’s Daughter is in fact a parallel retelling of the collapse of Rome, with the many political, economic, and social factors inherent in that empire’s fall relived and reinvented for the strange world of Judson’s future earth under Pan-Polarian rule.
In describing The Martian General’s Daughter as a ‘parallel account’ I mean to indicate that it is indeed a different sort of thing than what is more commonly seen, namely an author drawing inspiration or plot elements from a historical period such as George R.R. Martin’s channeling of the War of the Roses or Guy Gavriel Kay’s fantastical retellings of historical events. Judson does something different and accomplishes a thing I’ve never seen before in doing so. This is not an account of the fall of Rome in disguise as something else, nor is it an adoption of the environment of Late Antiquity as a kind of varnish on a extrapolation of future events, it isn’t even, as many people may think, an allegory on American power and influence, it is instead a reinvention of the world of tomorrow that transposes the historical logic of the Roman Empire upon the future — Judson does, in fact, put the fall of Rome in our future, and we of the Late Republic can marvel at our own collapse from the safe remove of three centuries. This world is so successfully drawn because it has little in the way of a logical dependence on our own time, and that otherworldliness, combined with a flawlessly evocative rendering of a declining and decadent civilization, makes for a masterpiece of world building. And the more one knows about Rome, the more parallels one uncovers, the greater the enjoyment and the more successfully rendered this world of the twenty-third century.
But this isn’t a slavish retelling of events, nor is it a kind of fictional history book of the future. From the first the reader is plunged into a world of political maneuverings and warfare, of generals, Emperors, assassins, and politicians. Justa, our guide to all this, reports with a sharp eye and clear voice the conflict her family has been drawn into. The book begins in 2293, the year that sees the start of civil war and General Black’s return from Mars. But the bulk of the story is in the past, and each alternating chapter details Black’s perilous existence under the mad reign of Luke Anthony and his falling in and out of favor over the years of Justa’s young adulthood. Those who know Roman history (or have gleaned a bit from Ridley Scott’s Gladiator) will recognize in the characters of Luke Anthony and his wise father Mathias the Glistening the persons of Commodus and Marcus Aurelius. Parallels such as this have a way of heightening expectations and of reinforcing associations in much the same way as a Shakespearian tragedy — in which the audience is already well-aware of the plot and resolution — evokes an even higher order of tension and suspense than that derived solely from the unraveling of the unknown.
As I’ve said it’s the known quantities and parallels that elevate this book above the run-of-the-mill tale of a secondary world, and it also helps it to achieve its oddness and capacity for surprise. Luke Anthony, like Commodus, fancies himself a gladiator and likes to show off at public games — his preferred mode being that of slaughtering hundreds of exotic animals with a high-powered rifle. Like Caligula, he thinks he is alternately a god and various figures of the mythological past such as Hercules or Tom Sawyer. We get something of the shock the Roman Senator must have felt upon being confronted by Caligula’s shenanigans when Luke Anthony and his intimates appear before the court in the guise of Tom, Huck Finn, and Jim. And just as Luke Anthony appears all the more insane because he is operating within parameters we recognize, in being tied to our own world of experience, so to do Judson’s themes resonate all the more profoundly because of their links, however tenuous, to our own reality.
General Black is the last good man to serve the Pan-Polarian Empire and, like Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus, he does his duty no matter the consequences to himself or others. Justa’s loving portrait of him shows him for his faults but also his great strengths, Black is a moral man and a loyal one, though unimaginative, ruthless, rigid, and unworldly. The illegitimate Justa is ever at his side, a reminder to him of a weak indiscretion on his part, and of whom he is ashamed during her early life — though her loyalty and devotion to him overcome such feelings with time. This is Black’s story, and sometimes he plays the role of dynamic force and at others the Holy Fool, but it is also very much Justa’s story, as she endures the uncertainty and chaos of life underneath a mad Emperor and remains ever loyal to her declining father — just as he holds fast to his own loyalty to an Empire in collapse. Both suffer for their loyalties, and both are heroic figures in their own way.
And indeed the whole world is suffering in the late twenty-third century, as bloody rebellions abroad and corrupt machinations at home ensure the people are the ones to suffer. Garden City is the great capital of Pan-Polaria, a teeming polyglot metropolis of forty million built on the bones of Mexico City — it is Constantinople to Washington DC’s Rome (and Washington, we are told, famously burned while the Emperor Darko flew a kite in Maryland). The Empire, which extends even to the other planets of the solar system, is shrinking, and the technologies it depends upon are disintegrating in the face of the metal plague. One military campaign illustrates that decline quite simply — it begins as a mechanized assault and ends on horseback. Over the course of the book things revert inexorably to the primitive, the Emperor’s Golden Hovercraft is replaced by a chariot, computers disappear, and the space colonies are cut off completely as both ship travel and communications become impossible. All of this creates a feel of decline more palpable than that provided by straight history, and I would recommend The Martian General’s Daughter to anyone that wants to get a feel for the collapse of the Roman System — it is a case of good fiction illuminating in ways non-fiction cannot.
But the appeal of this book goes well beyond just those readers interested in Rome — it is a treasure for fans of science fiction, future worlds, and the sorts of political intrigue and military adventure characteristic of stories of Empire. It takes the premise that ‘everything old is new again’ and makes it work in a completely satisfying way, all while creating vivid characters and real drama. This strange parallel future of Judson’s isn’t about history repeating itself and it isn’t about extrapolating current trends, rather it aims at exploring the universal themes of our political species and does so in a way at once rooted in the past and in the future — and in imagination. The Martian General’s Daughter gets my highest recommendation, and gets a place on the highest shelf of my personal pantheon.
“In Europe,” said Father, “you will build a new nation and I will grow old. The Empire will pass away, and in a thousand years your descendants will read of it in a language that does not yet exist, and they will wonder if these things really were. And even if they think the story of our age is no more real than the tales of Camelot and Troy, those in ages hence will know who among us were villains and those who were loyal to the things they held dear.”
The station, at this hour, is practically deserted. But in a moment I hear the wailing of onrushing wheels, metal on metal, and simultaneously I pick up the blasting impact of a phalanx of minds all rushing toward me at once out of the north, packed aboard the five or six cars of the oncoming train. The compressed souls of those passengers form a single inchoate mass, pressing insistently against me. They quiver like trembling jellylike bites of plankton squeezed brutally together in some oceanographer’s net, creating one complex organism in which the separate identities of all are lost. As the train glides into the station I am able to pick up isolated blurts and squeaks of discrete selfhood: a fierce jab of desire, a squawk of hatred, a pang of regret, a sudden purposeful inner mumbling, rising from the confusing totality the way odd little scraps and stabs of melody rise from the murky orchestral smear of a Mahler symphony. The power is deceptively strong in me today. . . . But I’m not deceived into thinking that the decline in my ability has been checked. . . . When one knows that something is dying inside one, one learns not to put much trust in the random vitalities of the fleeting moment. Today the power is strong yet tomorrow I may hear nothing but distant tantalizing murmurs.
There are philosophers who argue that there is no such thing as evil qua evil; that, discounting spells (which of course relieve an individual of responsibility), when a man commits an evil deed he is a victim himself, the slave of his progeniture and nurturing. Such philosophers might profit by studying Sanctuary. [from Joe Haldeman’s Blood Brothers]
The house stood on the hilltop, a huddled structure that had taken root and crouched close against the earth. So old that it was the color of the things around it, of grass and flowers and trees, of sky and wind and weather. A house built by men who loved it and the surrounding acres even as the dogs now loved them. Built and lived in and died in by a legendary family that had left a meteoric trail across centuries of time. Men who lent their shadows to the stories that were told around the blazing fireplace of stormy nights when the wind sucked along the eaves.
The debut issue of Darwin’s Evolutions just went online and it’s a promising premier. It’s got a great depth to it already, with fiction, articles, and graphic content as well as interviews, reviews, and an artist spotlight. The focus is on genre fiction, but the boundaries of genre are stretched by the sheer variety of the offerings, from articles for writers to manga reviews to a profile of a free fiction site to, of course, some genre-bending speculative fiction. In his editorial, Darwin Garrison lays out his simple requirements for Evolutions‘ fiction as follows: “. . . stories should be selected by how entertaining they are, not by some obscure literary standard or politically correct issue-content benchmark.” I couldn’t agree more.